Criticism

This month, MADE HERE explores criticism and how artists interact with it. The artists in these episodes have navigated a seemingly endless stream of criticism over the course of their careers—using negative reviews to better their performance, weeding out criticism that does not have at heart the best interest of art, and learning to maintain their identity while under a critical lens. The situation is even more complex in today’s critical landscape where everyone can have a blog and post an opinion.

Discussion Topics

Season 3 Episode Feedback

Reviews

Critics

DIY

Resources

Click for relevant news, organizations, and research.

Submit a resource

episode 3: DIY

In today’s world, anyone with an opinion and Internet access can be a critic. Blogging allows for a wider range of opinions to be heard and has become a crucial tool for artists to gain exposure. However, DIY criticism does not have the quality control of traditional review vehicles and can often add to the shallow, knee-jerk criticism that can hurt artists more than it helps. 

share this episode

View more episodes

resources

News

Critiquing Criticism: (re)imagining the future

A video of a recent panel of artists and critics discussing the future of arts criticism.

Where is our Tiki Barber? Theater Makers As Theater Critic

Commentary on why so few theater critics have a background in theater.

The Guardian, the cat and me – adventures in open journalism

An article about an English playhouse using open journalism to promote and reimage a classic play.

What are professional reviews for?

A blog post by Seth Godin analyzing today’s critical landscape.

The Role of Theater Criticism

An interview with critic David Cote on theater criticism.

Doing Time on the Other Side

John Longenbuagh recounts his experience working as a theater critic and how he balanced being both an artist and a critic.

Chloe Veltman on Arts Criticism

An interview with Chloe Veltman on arts criticism today compared to arts criticism in the past.

Critical Defense Posture

A blog post that brings together several excerpts with different views on the state of theater criticism today.

Short Shorts 78: Replying to critics and reviewing them

An article about critics reviewing the work of other critics.

Two Considerations for Criticism

An article on what critics should take into consideration when reviewing theater.

Crritic!

A blog on why criticism matters and the reasons for the recent outpouring of critics defending arts criticism.

What are critics for?

An article on the purpose of arts criticism.

Criticism! Eeek! Run! Run!

A article comparing professional criticism to criticism between artistic colleagues.

The Illumination Business: Why drama critics must look at and look after theater

Former New Yorker critic John Lahr voices his opinions on the problems with theater criticism today.

Criticism And Reviewing- “I’m Versus You. Completely Versus.”

A look at how critics reacted to John Lahr’s essay.

New York Drama Critics’ Circle

An organization of 24 of New York City’s top drama critics who vote on the annual New York Drama Critics’ Circle Award, the second oldest theater award in the United States.

Everyone’s a critic… even of Critics

An analysis of the current data collected HowlRound’s New York Times Critic Watch project.

More News Close

Organizations

International Association of Theatre Critics

The IATC draws together more than two thousand theatre critics from all over the world. Its principal aim is to foster theatre criticism as a discipline

American Theatre Critics Association

The American Theatre Critics Association is the only national association of professional theatre critics. Membership is open to all who review theatre professionally.

More Organizations Close

Research

Seven Tips for the Arts PR

Tips from an arts journalist on how PR departments can better the working relationships between themselves and journalists.

New York Times Critic Watch

A research project that uses user input on New York Times reviews to analyze the tone, temper and trends in theater reviews.

More Research Close

Season 3 Episode Feedback

What did you think about the episode?

  • David Cote said:

    I’ve written theater reviews for the past 13 years. And I read my colleagues’ work pretty regularly to see what they’re saying or what they choose to cover. As an artist, I’ve only gotten brief and superficial reviews here and there, nothing in New York. As an audience member I tend not to read reviews until after I see a work. Also, there are very few theater critics I trust or put much stock in. I’m more interested in critics in different fields: art, music, movies, etc. If an art show gets very positive reviews, I’ll go. Same for new opera or new production of an old opera.

    05/13 - 06:21 PM

  • Mia Anderson said:

    Yes. Criticism is a necessary component of creating art. It is a relationship that is symbolic and to make this relationship work we need both parties to be invested and knowledgeable about each of their arenas. Not just the generic yes or no but a thoughtful analysis that can support the development of art.

    05/19 - 06:34 PM

  • Jeremiah Clancy said:

    Yes! Absolutely. Critics need to have a historical context in which to base their views on. Or at least a working knowledge of the art of performance they are speaking about. Otherwise, criticism is reduced to opinion.

    05/19 - 06:34 PM

  • post a comment

    Your comment: